Rancher Mary Pluhar and author Susan Resnick, wearing the T-shirts Resnick had made for one of their visit.
I first met Sue Resnick, a petite powerhouse of a woman, via email. She had written a book called Goodbye Wifes and Daughters, about a small-town mining disaster in Montana, which we reviewed and then hired her to write a history article about for Montana Quarterly, the magazine I worked for as managing editor at the time.
Resnick lives on the East Coast, but was in Montana on vacation when the idea to write the book came to her. She and her family were watching pig races at the Bearcreek Saloon in Bearcreek, MT, and the saloon walls were covered with framed newspaper articles about the 1943 disaster. She read them and decided she wanted to read the book about it. “Turns out I had to write it first,” explains Resnick.
Resnick returned to Montana several times after her book was published to accept various awards, and on one of her trips emailed me and said, “I’m going to be in Bozeman. How about we meet in person somewhere fabulous for dinner?”
How could I refuse?
We had a great time, and before we said our goodbyes and returned to our very different lives, I felt connected, like we’d wasted no time sharing what was important with each other. It turns out that Resnick has a long resume of bridging gaps with strangers, which is how her most recent book, You Saved Me Too: What a holocaust survivor taught me about living, dying, fighting, loving and swearing in Yiddish, came to be.
It’s the story of a seemingly chance meeting where Resnick (then a mother of young children) finds herself conversing with Holocaust survivor Aron Lieb at a Jewish Community Center; what results is an intense 15 year friendship with a man who ends up with no one else to help him leave this world peacefully except for her. Resnick rises to the challenge, dealing with the present scars of his horrific past, all the while encountering nursing home and health care roadblocks she finds unthinkable for someone who has already suffered as much as her friend has.
This book-- and my dinner with Sue -- have left an imprint on me: you never know when you’ll meet someone you’ll never forget.
Q & A:
Before we get to your latest book, I have to ask you to explain the story behind the photo above:
While returning to MT several times to report, research and read from Goodbye Wifes, I met my first rancher, Mary Pluhar. We’d first met online after Homer Hickam, author of Rocket Boys and many books on his coal mining childhood, told me we’d like each other. We clicked and Mary drove from her ranch in Garfield County to my book launch in Red Lodge, where we first met in person. Since then, I’ve visited the ranch and she’s come to Boston to see me. We realized early on that she was the first rancher I’d ever met and I was the first Jewish person she’d ever met. I had the T-shirts in the photo made for us.
Supporting Aron (the main character in You Saved Me Too) required some bold fundraising efforts
from you. What was asking for money for Aron like for you?
The hardest part was asking his brother for money. The nursing home that I was hoping would cover some of his expenses told me I had to appeal to family first. His brother, who’d also survived the Holocaust and built a successful life for himself, wasn’t involved in Aron’s care even though they spoke regularly. When I asked him for financial help, he refused.
Did your family ever express frustration with the time and energy Aron required of you in his last few years?
It’s funny – everyone asks me this. The answer is absolutely not. I spent most of my time with Aron while my kids were at school and my husband at work. Even my Sunday visits didn’t seem to interfere with their lives. They saw it as just one of Mom’s activities.
This friendship required a lot of you. Were there moments when it felt like too much?
It only felt like too much when I was dealing with the mean people who wouldn’t help Aron. He would have liked me to visit him daily in the nursing home, which would have been too much, but I knew I had to limit that.
Have you always talked to strangers?
Yes. The first thing I said to my first friend from nursery school was, “You’re going to be my friend.” We had met three minutes earlier. Talking to strangers opens up the world.
Do you think we will lose something when the last remaining holocaust survivors and their stories slip away?
Some survivors could be as young as 70. We are definitely in danger of losing their stories. That’s one of the reasons I wrote about Aron’s history in the book. Since he had no children, I felt like the custodian of his memories.
You obviously have much to be proud about in your friendship with Aron. Looking back, is there anything you wish you’d said or done differently?
Not really. If I hadn’t made it to his bedside before he died or if he hadn’t had a peaceful death, I would have had many regrets. Luckily, neither of those things happened. I promised him he wouldn’t die alone and I got to fulfill that promise.
You are frank about your disappointment with various institutions and people in your community who didn’t help Aron when you approached them. Have you heard from any of them since the release of your book?
Yes. The president of the nursing home that I was so critical of invited me in for a talk. I was scared he was going to yell at me, but instead he apologized for the way Aron had been treated (he wasn’t involved with the institution at the time I was fighting with it) and offered to make changes so that Aron’s situation wouldn’t happen again.
Top three things that you learned from your friendship with Aron:
Don’t be afraid to speak out for what’s right. As long as babies aren’t dying (or a similar tragedy), nothing we complain about is that bad. Finding a soul mate has nothing to do with romance.
Your friendship with Aron allowed you to experience nursing homes and end-of-life scenarios in an intimate way. Has it changed how you are preparing for old age, etc.?
I’m actually not that scared of going to a nursing home. It seems like a college dorm for the elderly to me. If I have to move to one, I plan to live it up.